What’s the take home lesson, here?

I come home at nine thirty last night from a long day of work and school to find the house in an uproar.  My wife, mother-in-law and sister-in-law are locked in a pitched battle against my three year old nephew June-young.  These days Junie has had the very good fortune to sleep over our house with his favorite aunt (my wife) quite a bit and he’s grown very accustomed to it.  Now he doesn’t want to go home.  His mother is trying to convince him.

‘June-young, it’s time to go home, it’s ten o’clock.  Mommy’s tired.’  She is not lying.  She is a nurse and works very long hours, and yet she still goes through this rigmarole with him every time.

‘No, I don’t want to go home.  I hate you Mommy.  Aunt Miyoung, I don’t want to go!’  My wife says something sweetly about having to go, and how his mom is so tired and his dad wants to see him.  He begins crying.

This back-and-forth went on in front of me for about forty minutes, the whole while June-young becoming increasingly agitated, finally crying to the point of gagging.  I pointed out that when I was a kid and this situation arose, the adults around me basically ignored my desire to stay out forever.  ‘You’ll see them again next time,’ they’d say as I was hustled to the car.  I would sit down in the car and within five minutes of leaving I’d be fine, my mind occupied with something else.

To me this false presentation of choice seemed cruel.  When you bring a child to a doctor for a shot and she’s crying, you don’t try to wear her down with reason.  You give her a quick shot and a lollipop to calm her down.  All these fake attempts at reasoning with June-young was giving him was a headache and a sore throat from screaming.

Then this morning I realized that if you had to take a simple, ignorant guess which culture each of those parenting methods arose in, you’d probably guess wrong.  Confucian Korea would be more likely to sweep the child along without regard for their desires, while reason-loving America would tend to try to gain assent for every action from its kids, right?  What about in your own childhood or family?  What’s the best way of dealing with this all-too-common occurrence?

Advertisements

~ by Joe on March 26, 2008.

2 Responses to “What’s the take home lesson, here?”

  1. I’m an American too. And my experience is much the same as yours. My Dad is particularly annoyed by parents who try to reason with two year olds, or even five year olds. Young children are simply not equipped with the skills necessary for performing or even understanding logical analysis.

    I’m living in the Astoria neighborhood of New York City which is quite diverse ethnically, and I see many parents of small children from all over the world who are divided in trying to reason or trying to decree. I think the decree-ers are much more successful in keeping the tears to a minimal, and I think they are more pleased with their results.

    If children were capable of making their own decisions, they wouldn’t need parents, but they do. They do.

  2. Ah Astoria, where I was born and partly raised. Lovely place, which is still a serious melting pot and the perfect place from which to observe exactly this kind of situation.
    Thanks for the feedback, Tom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: